The band was about to kick off its summer tour “An Evening with Heart” at the Hard Rock Live at Etess Arena, when police say Garfield Bennett, a 57-year-old man from Pleasantville, walked into the venue and walked out with two priceless instruments — the now-recovered sparkle baritone guitar and a 1966 Gibson EM-50 mandolin.

A purple Telecaster guitar specially made for Heart member Nancy Wilson has been recovered, but a mandolin is still missing.

Surveillance footage was used to track down the instrument. A mandolin, which was taken at the same time, is still missing.